What is Tzom Gedalia?

After two days of serious prayer, introspection, and apples dipped in honey for a sweet year, many of us are probably still working off those Rosh Hashanah feasts. But just when we’re ready to focus on the final stretch toward Yom Kippur, along comes the fast of Tzom Gedalia.

Wait, what? Gedalia? Who was he again? And why do we fast for him?

Let’s be honest: Tzom Gedalia often gets overshadowed by the “bigger” fasts on the Jewish calendar. It can feel a bit random, and the story seems distant. A leader was assassinated thousands of years ago, and we’re still fasting? Why does this particular tragedy, out of so many in our history, deserve its own national day of mourning? And is there any significance to the fact that it falls on this specific date in the Jewish calendar?

The Historical Context

To understand why we fast on Tzom Gedalia, we might need a bit of a history lesson. After the Babylonians destroyed the First Temple and exiled most of the Jewish population, a small remnant remained in Israel. These survivors were leaderless, traumatized, and unsure of their future. Things were bleak, to say the least.

Enter Gedalia, son of Achikam, who the Babylonian king appointed to govern this small Jewish community. His appointment marked a glimmer of hope. He restored a sense of order, encouraged economic stability, and created a space for Jewish refugees to return home.

For a brief moment, it seemed like the Jewish people might have a second chance at survival. Gedalia’s leadership symbolized resilience, a chance to rebuild after catastrophic loss. But just as things were starting to look up, tragedy struck.

The Assassination of Gedalia

One of Gedalia’s former comrades, Yishmael ben Netanyah, conspired against Gedalia with a plot to kill him.

Yishmael’s motivations for assassinating Gedaliah were likely complex and layered, driven by both personal grievances and larger political machinations. Some commentators suggest that Yishmael, a descendant of the royal line, felt deeply slighted when he was passed over for the governorship of Judea.

Beyond personal motives, Yishmael may have viewed Gedaliah’s optimistic assertion that “all will be well” under Babylonian rule (Jeremiah 40:9) as tantamount to treason. Yishmael's disdain for Babylonian authority was likely intensified by their earlier brutal treatment of the royal family.

Yishmael’s actions were also entangled in broader regional politics. According to Jeremiah, King Baalis of Ammon played a significant role in orchestrating the assassination. Baalis, perhaps seeking to exploit the instability following the Babylonian invasion, saw an opportunity to gain influence or control in the power vacuum. He sent Yishmael to kill Gedaliah, possibly in the hope that chaos in Judea would benefit Ammon.

Yochanan ben Kareach, a former captain of the Judean army, tried to warn Gedalia, first publicly, and then privately, that Yishmael was coming to kill him, but Gedalia refused to believe that a fellow Jew could harbor such treacherous intentions. Gedalia wasn’t just being naïve; he was trying to lead with hope. He wanted to foster trust and unity in a deeply fractured and traumatized community. In his mind, suspecting Yishmael, or any Jew for that matter, of such heinous betrayal would only deepen the divisions among the already fragile Jewish population.

But Yishmael’s hatred ran deep. Determined to carry out his plan, Yishmael and his men arrived at Gedalia’s home in Mitzpah under the guise of friendship. The day? Rosh Hashanah. They shared a holiday meal with Gedalia, appearing to offer peace and camaraderie. It should have been a moment of trust and reconciliation. Yet, as they broke bread, Yishmael and his accomplices murdered Gedalia in cold blood.

His assassination led to the scattering of the Jewish survivors and marked the final nail in the coffin of Jewish self-governance. The remaining Jews fled to Egypt, and for the first time since the days of Joshua, the continuous Jewish presence in the land came to an end.

This event was more than just the loss of one leader—it was the collapse of a fragile rebuilding effort. The assassination of Gedalia represented the end of hope for the Jews left in Israel.

Why We Fast

So, why do we fast on Tzom Gedalia? The fast isn’t just a remembrance of a political assassination; it’s a recognition of what Gedalia’s death symbolizes—the destruction of the last vestiges of Jewish sovereignty in the land of Israel. It’s a day to reflect on the consequences of internal divisions, betrayal, and missed opportunities.

In a way, Tzom Gedalia is an extension of the mourning we do on Tisha B’Av. While Tisha B’Av focuses on the destruction of the Temple and the exile of the Jewish people, Tzom Gedalia zeroes in on the aftermath—the final unraveling of Jewish life in the land after the Babylonian conquest.

But there’s a broader lesson here, too. The tragedy of Gedalia’s assassination reminds us of the dangers of internal discord. Gedalia was killed not by a foreign enemy but by a fellow Jew. Yishmael’s betrayal highlights the damage we can do to ourselves when we allow jealousy, mistrust, and political ambitions to tear us apart from within.

Finding Relevance Today

At first glance, the story of Gedalia may seem like ancient history, but the themes it touches on are all too familiar. We’ve seen throughout history—and it’s especially relevant today—how societies are often weakened more by internal strife than by external threats. When people turn on each other, when trust breaks down, everything falls apart.

Tzom Gedalia is a reminder that the Jewish people, and any community really, are at their strongest when they work together, even in difficult times. And, conversely, we’re at our most vulnerable when we let internal divisions lead to destruction.

It’s no coincidence that Tzom Gedalia comes just days after Rosh Hashanah. Aside from the fact that the assassination of Gedalia took place on Rosh Hashanah, Rosh Hashanah is also a time when we focus on unity and repairing relationships. As we move from the sweetness of Rosh Hashanah to the solemnity of Yom Kippur, Tzom Gedalia calls us to reflect on the role we play in maintaining unity and trust in our own communities.

In "The Hidden Meaning Behind Tzom Gedaliah," Rivky Stern offers us an in-depth look at the story behind this often-overlooked fast, shedding light on its significance and relevance to our lives today.

Dive Deeper

To learn more about upcoming Jewish holidays, check out these Aleph Beta videos:

Rosh Hashanah Preparation: How To Prepare For Rosh Hashanah | Aleph Beta

What Is The Meaning Of Yom Kippur | Aleph Beta

Why Do We Celebrate Sukkot | Aleph Beta

Is Hoshana Rabba the Key to Understanding Sukkot? | Aleph Beta